traineo community
Member of traineo? Sign in here
traineo Community / Off-Topic & General Chat / Planet Fitness in NYT : "member evicted for grunting while working out"
Author Message
Leo -
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 113

Post History
# Posted: 18 Nov 2006 05:55


I just had to laugh, in a way it's sad but still.


No Grunting, They Told Him, and He Was at Gym


Vrinda GetsFit
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 198

Post History
# Posted: 18 Nov 2006 22:17


I have been guilty of an involuntary "owwww" or two in my gym-life, at the end of a set. But I am no grunter. Yet, I'd never sign up at that gym in the article. I'd take one look at the rules, and tell them I'm taking my membership someplace that likes their members.


Leo -
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 113

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 04:30


I grunt, can't help it. Yogic breathing is better but I forget to do that more often than not.


NYCinephile .
Fitness Guru
Posts: 328

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 05:45


New York City's Gothamist comments on the story.


Vrinda GetsFit
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 198

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 06:48


Leo: You are welcome to gyms in India if you ever encounter grunt-discrimination. I dont grunt because I dont lift weights that are heavy enough to need vocal encouragement to move from point a to point b. But a lot of the people in my gym grunt. If anything they get an appreciate nod from the non-grunters for their efforts and daring.

Yoga is about never forcing. So the rule of no-mouth breathing and always practicing without any strain on your face ( a smile if you can manage that), match with yoga. Incidentally ujayi breathing does create a hum in your throat. And Om breathing creates a powerful reverberation when a room of yogis are in the groove.

Heavy lifting and grunting belong together.

NYCinephile: I liked the term in your link: show-grunters. Those can get a bit annoying. But not enough to warrant an eviction.

I am amazed that a club can revoke a membership. Do they refund fees when they do that? If they dont, are they allowed by American laws to get away with it?


NYCinephile .
Fitness Guru
Posts: 328

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 07:26


@Vrinda: I'm not quite sure what the policies and applicable law are. Gyms in Manhattan are as packed as subway cars during rush hour. This is one of the reasons I choose to work out at home.


Leo -
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 113

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 16:20


Quoting: Vrinda
ujayi breathing does create a hum in your throat

Yea, I put down 'yogic breathing' and then realized that I didn't know enough to talk about it. I was referring to a controlled exhalation more like blowing out a candle than by blocking the air at the back of the throat.

I sit here writing this, making strange 'uhh' and gurgling sounds to be sure of what I mean. Hope no-one's listening.

Quoting: NYCinephile
Gyms in Manhattan are as packed as subway cars

I bet. When I lived in San Francisco, tried going to a major gym and it was too much. Found a smaller neighborhood place to go instead. Not living in a metro area anymore, I still prefer for the smaller single-owner gyms.


Snakeophelia S
traineo Regular
Posts: 35

Post History
# Posted: 19 Nov 2006 22:57


There's a great gym near where I work - with NO parking lot, and all the evening classes start before the evening parking spots open up. Grrrr....

I sing along with my mp3 player when I work out, which, given my voice, is probably MUCH more offensive than anyone's grunting.


Vrinda GetsFit
traineo Fanatic
Posts: 198

Post History
# Posted: 20 Nov 2006 02:52


Snakeophelia,

Hey! I'd love to workout next to you. Especially if your voice is really as bad as you claim. You singing out of tune, lost to the rest of the world while you pedal furiously (or whatever), is such a cute mental picture. The reaction of other gym goers (amused, startled, ?) will be very entertaining too.

Vrinda


Matthew Frederick
traineo Regular
Posts: 39

Post History
# Posted: 20 Nov 2006 17:32


I'm fortunate to have some decent gym equipment at home, as I'm certain that I'd be kicked out for singing and acting like an idiot in general, "conducting" the music I'm listening to, "playing" along with the drums, air guitaring, etc.

Actually, it's probably pretty amusing for about 20 seconds.


Please sign up to traineo or log in if you wish to post.
 
© traineo 2007